Geographers analyzed 175 satellite images of ocean colour, which is an indicator of Phytoplankton productivity at the ocean's surface, and found that giant icebergs are responsible for storing up to 20 percent of carbon in the Southern Ocean. The researchers discovered that melting water from giant icebergs which contains iron and other nutrients, supports hitherto unexpectedly high levels of phytoplankton growth.
Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made : Which of the assumptions given above is/ are valid?
Correct Answer: (A) 1 only
30 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS Assumption 1 is valid: The passage states that the melting water from giant icebergs contains nutrients that support high levels of phytoplankton growth. It is common knowledge that phytoplankton are found in ocean, and form a crucial part of the ocean's primary productivity as they are consumed by fish, thus forming the base of the marine food chain. Therefore, it is safe to extend our understanding of the lines of the passage to the impact on primary productivity and food chains of the Southern Ocean. Furthermore, the option statement uses accommodative words such as ‘bearing’, which forms the base for a valid assumption. *However, there is a possibility that this assumption be taken as invalid: The passage primarily focuses on the impact of giant icebergs on phytoplankton productivity and carbon storage, without explicitly connecting these effects to the broader food chain. While it is logical to infer that phytoplankton growth influences the food chain, the passage does not explicitly make this connection. Assumption 2 is not valid: While the passage mentions that giant icebergs store carbon and support phytoplankton growth, it does not explicitly discuss the broader climate change effects or the impact on world fisheries. Although it is plausible that changes in primary productivity in the Southern Ocean could have wider implications, this is not properly covered in the passage (to consider this assumption to be valid). Furthermore, the passage mentions the Southern Ocean, whereas the option mentions and extends the assumption to world fisheries. The connection between the two is again not established in the passage.