Consider the following: Statement: Good voice is a natural gift but one has to keep practising to improve and well in the field of music. Conclusions: I. Natural gifts need nurturing and care. II. Even though one's voice is not good, one can keep practising. Which one of the following is correct, in respect of the above statement and conclusions?
Correct Answer: (D) Neither conclusion I nor conclusion II follows from the statement.
Correct Answer: (D) Neither conclusion I nor conclusion II follows from the statement.
Detailed Step-by-Step Analysis:
In UPSC CSE Prelims 2017 CSAT (GS Paper-II, Question 75), the officially verified answer is Option (D): "Neither conclusion I nor conclusion II follows from the statement.". This question tests Logical Reasoning (Analytical & Logical Reasoning).
Worked Solution:
The charateristic of good voice may not be applicable to all natural gifts. Hence, statement 1 cannot be concluded. Statement 2 can also not be concluded as passage does not comment on cases where voice is not good. Hence, option (d) is the correct answer.
Option Verification & Elimination:
Evaluating the problem constraints confirms (D) "Neither conclusion I nor conclusion II follows from the statement." as the unique valid solution, eliminating (A) Only conclusion I follows from the statement.; (B) Only conclusion II follows from the statement.; (C) Either conclusion I or conclusion II follows from the statement..
CSAT Approach & Exam Strategy:
• Section & Topic: CSAT Paper-II › Logical Reasoning › Analytical & Logical Reasoning.
• How to Solve Faster: Diagram the given constraints step by step (family tree, direction grid, seating layout, or Venn diagram) before evaluating options. Avoid assuming unstated relationships and verify every condition against the final choice.
• Scoring Benchmark: +2.5 marks for correct, −0.833 negative marking (target ~90 seconds/question; 66.67/200 required to qualify).