Correct Answer: (D) All those who travel by air are rich.
Official UPSC CSE Prelims 2012 CSAT (Paper-II, Series A) Answer Key: (D).
Step-by-Step Solution (IAS SETU — Syllogism & True/False):
Given that, 1. None but the rich can afford air-travel. 2. Some of those who travel by air become sick 3. Some of those who become sick require treatment Now, Option analysis: (a) All the rich persons travel by air False - Though rich can afford air travel but they does not travel only by air (b) Those who travel by air become sick False - Though some of those who travel by air become sick but it cannot be concluded with certainty (c) All the rich persons become sick False - This cannot be concluded with certainty (d) All those who travel by air are rich True - With the given information: None but the rich can afford air-travel, it can be concluded. Hence option (d) is correct