A mobile phone has been stolen. There are 3 suspects P, Q and R. They were questioned knowing that only one of them is guilty. Their responses are as follows: P: I did not steal. Q stole it. Q: R did not steal. I did not steal. R: I did not steal. I do not know who did it. Who stole the mobile phone?
Correct Answer: (A) P
One of them is guilty, and hence must be lying. We need to see the logical consistency of the three statements even when one of them is lying. Case I: P is lying, while Q and R are telling the truth It means that, P stole the mobile phone. Now, we need to check whether statements made by Q and R are also consistent or not. If P was the thief, then it’s obvious R and Q did not steal. So, statement made by Q seems valid. If P was the thief, then it’s obvious R did not steal. So, statement made by R seems valid too. This case seems to be the correct one. Hence, P stole the mobile phone. But let’s quickly go through the other two possible cases. Case II: Q is lying, while P and R are telling the truth As per P, Q was the thief. However, as Q is lying, there are two thieves (both Q and R). This is logically inconsistent. Case III: R is lying, while P and Q are telling the truth As per P, Q was the thief. However, as R is lying, R must be the thief. This is logically inconsistent. Note: Here, we are assuming that when a person lies, both his statements are a lie. In case, these people are lying partially (one statement is a true, while the other is false), then the answer would be option (d). For example, in Case II mentioned above, if in Q’s statement, “R did not steal.” is true, and “I did not steal.” is false, then it means that Q was the thief. 52 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS